The 10 Best Oven Mitts of 2023

Jun 27, 2023

KitchenAid’s Asteroid Oven Mitt features handy silicone grips and comes in multiple colors to fit any kitchen decor style.

Jump to a Section

We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more.

Better Homes & Gardens / Reese Herrington

Having the right kitchen accessories is important, especially if you spend a lot of time cooking or baking. One essential kitchen accessory is a good oven mitt.

We researched various styles and sizes of oven mitts, taking into consideration material, heat resistance, and care. We also consulted Chris Alexakis, kitchen design expert and founder of CabinetSelect, who provided helpful hints about what to look for when shopping for the best oven mitts.

Amazon

These mitts are made of cotton and silicone to resist heat and help you securely hold hot pans, and there are 23 colors to choose from.

The silicone grips are arranged in a pattern of tiny hearts, which may not appeal to everyone.

This set of two oven mitts from KitchenAid has our vote for the best oven mitt overall. The mitts are crafted from heat-resistant cotton to protect your hands as you pull freshly baked goods directly from the oven.

The mitts have silicone grips arranged in a pattern, which helps you securely hang on to hot dishes or pots. Note the pattern is made up of tiny heart shapes, which may not appeal to everyone, but they’re small and subtle.

The 12.5 x 7-inch mitts are machine washable, so there’s no need to worry if you get a bit of food on these. If you want to store them in a cupboard, save some space by adding a hook to the inner cabinet door, then hang them up using the attached loops. Or, choose your favorite color from the 23 available options and hang them on a kitchen wall to display them instead.

Price at time of publish: $28

Product Details: Size: 12.5 x 7 x 0.13 inches | Material: Cotton, silicone | Machine Washable: Yes

Target

These oven mitts are certified to be free from more than 350 chemicals.

These are only available at Target and come in one color (light gray).

Sold individually, this oven mitt is the best budget option since it costs just $3. Made from 100% cotton, these light gray oven mitts are easy to clean since they go right into your washing machine. They are also textured, which provides a bit more grip as you’re transporting hot pots and pans from oven to table.

The mitts are certified by OEKO-TEX to be free from more than 350 harmful chemicals, which adds a little peace of mind to your daily cooking and baking. These budget-friendly mitts are available in just one neutral color. You’ll also need to buy this directly from Target, as it’s a store brand.

Price at time of publish: $3

Product Details: Size: 12.5 x 7 inches | Material: Cotton | Machine Washable: Yes

Amazon

You can also use this item as an oven mitt, making it a highly versatile kitchen staple.

The shorter, rounded shape may not provide as much protection for your wrists.

This is the best oven mitt that also doubles as a pot holder. For use as an oven mitt, insert your hand into the fabric-lined interior to take a hot pan out of the oven. Or place the pot holder onto your table or counter as a trivet for hot pans to let them cool before serving.

Silicone is used on one side of the pot holder, providing you with a better grip on pan handles that are piping hot. It’s heat-safe, of course, but it also resists flames, stains, and steam, making it a durable pot holder. The shorter, rounded shape doesn’t include a cuff, so it won’t protect your wrists from a hot oven.

Cleaning up is easy since you can throw it right into the washing machine. If only the silicone side becomes dirty, simply wipe it off with a damp cloth.

Price at time of publish: $13

Product Details: Size: 9 x 7.5 x 0.75 inches | Material: Silicone, fabric | Machine Washable: Yes

Amazon

These heat-resistant mitts provide extra protection from burns on arms and wrists if you’re reaching deep into a hot oven.

The extended cuff may be too long for those with shorter forearms.

These extra-long oven mitts from DoMii are the best option for someone who wants a little extra heat protection while cooking. Specifically, the cuff on each mitt is 19.5 inches long, making it elbow-length.

These are great if you frequently reach into deep ovens as they offer extra protection from burns on the wrist or forearm. Because they’re extra long, make sure you have space to store the mitts in a cabinet because they may not fit in a kitchen drawer.

They have a silicone exterior with grips for more secure handling. The extended cuff is fabric, but it’s heat-resistant up to 464°F, preventing most burns. Be aware that the cuffs may be too long for people with shorter arms. The interior is lined with quilted cotton, so you’ll stay comfortable while transferring pots and pans in and out of the oven.

These are machine washable and can even go in the dishwasher, making cleanup incredibly easy.

Price at time of publish: $24

Product Details: Size: 19.5 x 7.4 inches | Material: Silicone, polyester, cotton | Machine Washable: Yes

Amazon

These oven mitts are designed to fit over the fingers and thumb rather than the entire hand.

These mitts need to be hand-washed, so they require a bit of extra cleanup time.

Not everyone’s hands are the same size, and it’s important to find oven mitts that fit you. If you or someone at home has smaller hands, these mini oven mitts are your best bet. They’re made of neoprene, polyester, and cotton and are designed to cover just your fingertips. The shorter length (10.5 x 6 inches) keeps your hands from sliding around in a traditional oven mitt that may be too large.

These require hand-washing, which is a little less convenient and slightly more time-consuming. However, they come in a set of two, and you can choose your favorite from four colors. Plus, their smaller size makes them easier to store in an already-crowded kitchen drawer. They’re heat-resistant up to 400°F and are lined with cotton and insulation for heat protection with comfort.

Price at time of publish: $18

Product Details: Size: 10.25 x 6 x 3 inches | Material: Neoprene, polyester, cotton | Machine Washable: No

Sur La Table

The charming pattern lends a colorful pop to kitchens of all styles.

There is no silicone for extra protection and grip.

If you appreciate a bit of subtle flair with your kitchen accessories, this is the best oven mitt for you. The 12 x 7-inch mitt is available in a warm golden hue or subdued sage green. Each color has a timeless Buffalo check pattern, which fits in with nearly any type of home decor scheme.

Diamond quilting provides extra cushioning for comfort and protection. As this mitt has no silicone layer, heat and slip resistance won’t be as high on this more decorative mitt. But the cotton construction makes it easy to clean and manipulate. When it gets dirty, simply toss the mitt into the washing machine. Hang it up as a useful display with the hanging loops, or tuck it into a drawer when not in use.

Price at time of publish: $15

Product Details: Size: 12 x 7 inches | Material: Cotton| Machine Washable: Yes

Amazon

These mitts resist higher temps and stains, and they’re waterproof.

These oven mitts are not machine washable.

Fans of colorful kitchenware will appreciate that these 12.5-inch mitts come in a dozen shades. The silicone exterior of these oven mitts resists heat up to 484°F, while the interior lining is made from cotton for added comfort. The silicone material is flexible, so they are easy to wear. This material also provides additional help gripping onto pots, pans, or hot casserole dishes.

Though these oven mitts aren’t machine washable, they are waterproof and resistant to stains. Cleaning them involves a quick rinse under running water. Or, for a more thorough cleaning, rinse them with soap and water in the kitchen sink after an extra messy (but delicious!) dinner. Hang these up to dry and store them using their convenient cotton loops.

Price at time of publish: $30

Product Details: Size: 12.5 inches long | Material: Silicone, polyester | Machine Washable: No

Amazon

This high-quality mitt comes in a multitude of classic seasonal designs at an affordable price.

Heat resistance may not be as high as other more utilitarian picks on our list.

If you’re a holiday decorating aficionado, then you know the importance of adding magical holiday flair to every room. Outfit your kitchen appropriately with this beautiful mitt that features seasonal berries and foliage on a festive red background. Sold as a single mitt or part of a set, any of the classic holiday designs available would make a great hostess gift or simply buy a pair to enjoy yourself.

These quilted cotton mitts can go right into your washing machine. The manufacturer notes they can be tumble dried, but based on our expert’s tips, it’s best to hang dry to avoid potential shrinking or fraying. That way, you’ll be able to enjoy them for many holiday seasons.

Price at time of publish: $14

Product Details: Size: 13 x 7.5 inches | Material: Cotton | Machine Washable: Yes

Walmart

This complete set comes in seven appealing colors and offers great quality at an even better price.

The items can’t be purchased individually.

Having a set of oven mitts and pot holders is convenient. It’s also nice if you appreciate matching kitchen accessories. This set includes one oven mitt, one pot holder, and two mini mitts made from cotton and polyester materials. Available in black, gray, blue, yellow, red, green, and indigo, there is a solid color choice for every home chef.

Because of the silicone wrapped exterior, the mitts and pot holder easily grip dishes without sliding around, giving you a better grasp as you’re pulling out your favorite lasagna from the oven. This is incredibly helpful for safety reasons, of course.

At less than $20, this timeless set is an affordable kitchen essential for college students or new homeowners. Plus, the cotton blend mitts and pot holder are machine washable for easy cleanup.

Price at time of publish: $13

Product Details: Size: 13 x 7 x 1 inches | Material: Cotton, polyester | Machine Washable: Yes

Amazon

It offers better grip and mobility, which is great for barbecuing, smoking, or grilling.

Getting a good fit can be trickier with this style of glove.

These are the best oven mitts in a glove style, with a place for each finger rather than mittens. They’re especially handy for barbecue enthusiasts who need a bit more dexterity while barbecuing or grilling. It can be trickier to get the sizing just right on this type of glove, which is why it’s helpful that you can choose from two sizes (10.8 x 7.2 inches or 12 x 7.08 inches) when you order them.

The exterior is made of silicone, while the interior is lined with “anti-sweat” cotton. The manufacturer doesn’t provide cleaning instructions, so it’s best if you hand-wash these. These gloves come with three electronic recipe books for culinary inspiration and two hooks for easy storage.

Price at time of publish: $45

Product Details: Size: 10.8 x 7.2 x 1.1 inches (standard); 12 x 7.08 x 1.37 inches (extra large) | Material: Cotton, silicone | Machine Washable: Not listed

Overall, the best oven mitt is the KitchenAid Asteroid Oven Mitt, which features heat-resistant cotton and silicone construction, and is available in 23 colors for added personalization.

Look for oven mitts that fit your hands “comfortably and securely,” says Chris Alexakis, kitchen design expert and founder of CabinetSelect. You’ll want to consider your hand size as well as the amount of protection you’d like from the mitt.

It’s worth measuring potential oven mitts to make sure they’ll fit wherever you plan to stash them. Some oven mitts are larger and thicker, so they may not fit as well in a small drawer by your stove, for instance. Be sure you take into account where you plan to store the mitts before selecting new ones.

Your best bet is to find oven mitts made from “durable, heat-resistant materials such as cotton or neoprene,” says Alexakis. Oven mitts made of silicone are another solid choice. Beyond ensuring your oven mitts are heat-resistant, choosing a material often comes down to personal preference.

Cotton and synthetic oven mitts can typically go into the washing machine for easy cleaning, says Alexakis. Silicone oven mitts can generally be wiped clean. Make sure you read the manufacturer’s instructions to determine the best way to clean your oven mitts.

Both items are designed to help you handle hot items in the kitchen. Alexakis tells us the major difference comes down to design and the way they’re used.

“Oven mitts are typically made of fabric and are designed to fit around the entire hand, providing greater protection against heat than pot holders.”

On the other hand, pot holders are generally constructed from fabric or terry cloth and are on the smaller side, so they’re a little easier to store.

Alexakis says that the majority of oven mitts can be run through your washing machine on a cold, gentle cycle. He cautions that you should always check the instructions before tossing them into the wash. And if you end up with stains, a pre-soak in mild detergent and warm water can be helpful.

Alexakis advises that you avoid bleach, fabric softener, and tumble drying to keep the mitts from fraying or possibly shrinking. You’ll generally want to wipe silicone oven mitts clean rather than machine washing them.

According to Alexakis, cotton and synthetics like neoprene or silicone are commonly used in oven mitts. He explains that cotton tends to be “durable, breathable, and heat-resistant” while synthetics “are particularly good at insulating against heat and can provide extra protection.” As long as your oven mitts are safe to use at hot temperatures, the best material is whatever works well for you.

This article was written by Brittany VanDerBill, a freelance lifestyle and travel writer whose work has been published with several Dotdash Meredith brands. To find the best oven mitts, she researched various options, keeping in mind size, material, and design, amongst other details. She also consulted Chris Alexakis, kitchen design expert and founder of CabinetSelect.